Home / Blog / Appeals court reverses decision, CDC rules on cruises are no longer binding

Appeals court reverses decision, CDC rules on cruises are no longer binding


Another day, another update on the legal battle between the CDC and the cruise industry! News reports are stating that the most recent decision on cruises is no longer binding.

SeaTrade-Cruise.com is reporting, “The US Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit on Friday vacated its order granting the CDC a stay of a lower court’s decision.

Judge Merryday’s order stands

Therefore, US District Judge Steven Merryday’s June 18 ruling overturning the conditional sailing order is in effect and the CSO is now a non-binding ‘consideration,’ ‘recommendation’ or ‘guideline’ instead of a requirement.

The appeals panel denied the CDC’s motion to stay Merryday’s order because the appellants failed to meet the required standards.

The decision was ‘sua sponte,’ meaning it didn’t result from further petition by any party. 

Legal experts speculated that the court initially issued its stay because of the impending July 18 deadline for the order to become effective. Then, upon further reflection and analysis, the panel decided not to stay the lower court’s decision, pending the appeal.

CDC appeal will continue

The CDC’s appeal will continue in its normal course. However, in the meantime, Merryday’s order remains in effect.

Does this mean any immediate change in cruise line COVID-19 protocols?

Earlier, a cruise industry operations expert told Seatrade Cruise News that regardless of the decision in the Florida case, lines would probably stick to the CDC policies because ‘the results have been positive so far, and keeping these policies in place will reassure the public cruising is safe.’”

Stay tuned to TheCruiseGenius.com for updates on the new Carnival Mardi Gras and the legal back and forth with the courts and the CDC!

Carnival Mardi Gras

Click on the link below for the full story mentioned in this blog post


About Scott Lara

Navy Veteran, Travel Agent, love to cruise!

Check Also

Cruise Planners trailblazer Vicky Garcia passes away.

Vicky Garcia   Cruise Planners corporate announced on their LinkedIn page that Vicky Garcia has …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.